Refugee Law

Today refugee law is a very controversial subject since the people of South Africa are deeply divided on the question of foreign nationals residing in the country, whether they are doing so legally or illegally.

Refugee law is intended to safeguard individuals who have to leave their homes since they are facing either a serious present or imminent danger. The principle upon which it is based is that nobody should be compelled to go back to a country where their life or freedom is in danger. This set of rules arises from international agreements as well as from national laws, and South Africa, together with many other countries, has incorporated these principles into its own legislation.

International point of view

[1]The 1951 Convention and 1967 Protocol Modern refugee protection is based on the 1951 United Nations Convention relating to the status of refugees and on its 1967 Protocol. The two documents were developed in the period following the Second World War, when large numbers of people had been made homeless. At first the Convention was concerned only with people who had fled events in Europe before 1951; the 1967 Protocol then got rid of both the temporal and territorial restrictions so that the rules could apply everywhere. A refugee is defined as a person who is outside their country of origin and who is unable or unwilling to return due to a well-founded fear of persecution. This fear must be based on race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion.

Moreover, the Convention includes individuals who are compelled to leave their country as a result of external aggression, occupation, or events which seriously disturb public order. The Convention is guided by three main principles. The first is non-discrimination: the rules have to be applied without showing any preference on the grounds of race, religion, or country of origin. The second is non-penalisation: refugees should not be punished just because they have entered a country without the correct documents in the situation where they are looking for safety. The third and most important one is non-refoulement: a country must not return a refugee to a place where their life or freedom would be at risk. This principle is so basic that no exceptions can be made to it. The Convention also includes minimum standards relating to the treatment of refugees. They should have access to the courts, be given the opportunity to receive primary education, have the right to work, and be provided with identity and travel documents. Many states put out a special refugee travel document which works in the same way as a passport.

South African point of view

South Africa has signed the 1951 Convention, the 1967 Protocol, and the 1969 Organisation of African Unity Convention, which deals with refugee issues particular to Africa, and it has implemented these obligations by means of the Refugees Act 130 of 1998 (as amended).[2] The Act gives the definition of a refugee one which is very similar to the international definition; someone meets the criteria if they have a well-founded fear of being persecuted for the reasons mentioned above or if they have been compelled to leave their country due to war, foreign domination or serious public disorder, and spouses and/or other family members of recognised refugees are also entitled to protection. The Act provides practical procedures for dealing with claims. Asylum seekers make their applications at the Refugee Reception Offices. Decisions may be examined by the Standing Committee for Refugee Affairs and there is also a Refugee Appeals Authority. After their status has been granted, refugees acquire certain rights, namely the right not to be returned to danger, access to identity documents, and in some cases the possibility of staying indefinitely. Refugee status is not permanent in all cases. Under Section 5 of the Act the situation in which it can end is set out. A common example of this is when a person voluntarily avails themselves again of the protection offered by their country of origin—for instance, by getting a national passport and using it. Section 36 enables the Standing Committee to take away the status if the person no longer meets the requirements or if certain other conditions occur. In any such case fair procedures must be followed.

Case Law

[3]The way in which these rules function in practice can be seen from a recent decision by the High Court in Gauteng (M M v Chairperson of the Standing Committee for Refugee Affairs, October 2025). The person who had applied was a specialist doctor from the Democratic Republic of Congo and had originally been granted refugee status before having it certified as being capable of remaining a refugee indefinitely. Many years later the authorities tried to have that status withdrawn since he had acquired a Congolese passport, considering this to be an act of availing himself of the protection of his country of origin. The court identified serious procedural flaws. The initial decision to withdraw was reached without properly taking into account the applicant’s remarks. After this decision had been communicated, the Standing Committee became “functus officio”, that is, it had completed its duties and thus could not merely reverse or re-make the decision on its own. It was therefore unlawful to make the second attempt to withdraw the status. The court annulled both decisions and reaffirmed that the applicant would remain a refugee indefinitely. It also instructed the authorities to pay the costs at a higher rate due to the way the case had been dealt with.

This situation illustrates two practical considerations. The first is that even though the law permits status to be withdrawn, the process has to be fair and legal. The second is that after a formal decision has been made and communicated, authorities cannot simply reverse it; they must take the correct legal steps. This matters because Refugee law strikes a balance between the right of individuals to seek safety and the practical situation encountered by the countries that host them. It does not grant an automatic right to permanent residence or citizenship, but it does ensure basic protection from being sent back to a dangerous situation and a minimum number of rights during the time that protection is in force. For most people, the main point is simple: if a person genuinely fears serious harm because of who they are or what they believe, both International and South African law offer a framework under which that claim can be carefully examined and the person is treated with dignity while the claim is being decided.

The system isn’t perfect, as is shown by the case mentioned above in which errors do occur. It is the courts’ responsibility to rectify those errors and to ensure that the process remains accountable.

[1] The 1951 Refugee Convention and 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees | UNHCR

[2] SAFLII – REFUGEES ACT 130 OF 1998

[3] M M v Chairperson of Standing Committee for Refugee Affairs and Others (2023-074862) [2025] ZAGPJHC 2364 [LawLibrary] (17 October 2025) – LawLibrary